0308NCBAAsksforHageCaseSett.cfm Malatya Haber PLC, NCBA ask Supreme Court to settle Hage case
Home News Livestock Crops Markets Hay, Range & Pasture Home & Family Classifieds Resources This Week's Journal
Commerical Hay Equipment For The Farm
Agro-Culture Liquid Fertilizer

Farm Survey

Journal Getaways

Reader Comment:
by Eliza Winters

"I think that the new emission standards are a great move. I think that the"....Read the story...
Join other discussions.

PLC, NCBA ask Supreme Court to settle Hage case

Public Lands Council and the National Cattlemen's Beef Association are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to take up and settle a decades-long property rights case, Hage v. United States. The high court would determine whether the U.S. Forest Service violated the Takings Clause of the U.S. Constitution when it interfered with Nevada ranchers Wayne and Jean Hage's stock water rights.

PLC and NCBA were joined by Nevada Cattlemen's Association, Oregon Cattlemen's Association and Washington Cattlemen's Association in their brief of amicus curiae, filed by Western Resources Legal Center.

"We believe that the case's precedent-setting nature and importance to livestock producers' property rights merits the Supreme Court's consideration," said Brice Lee, Colorado rancher and PLC president. "They deserve compensation for what the Forest Service took from them. Ranchers cannot operate without access to the water that is legally theirs."

The U.S. Forest Service had denied the Hage family access to ditches supplying their stock and several meadows with water. The agency demanded that the family file for a permit in order to maintain and use the water. Although a federal claims court decided the Hages were owed compensation by the agency for the water taking, the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals reversed this determination in part.

"This case threatens the ability to carry out livestock activities both on and off federal land," said WRLC Executive Director and representing Counsel Caroline Lobdell. "The federal agency, in effect, would be armed with the authority to unilaterally determine what constitutes reasonable or routine maintenance, and therefore empowered to subjugate vested 1866 Mining Act rights-of-way in favor of whatever policy rules the day."

According to NCBA President and Wyoming rancher Scott George, if the agency is allowed to demand a permit for Hage's ditch right-of-way, county road rights-of-way established under the Mining Act (known as "R.S. 2477 roads") would also be in jeopardy. This would further threaten ranchers' ability to stay in business, George said, since they often depend on those roads to access their grazing allotments.

Lee summed up the case's importance to livestock producers nation-wide. "The implications to livestock producers at-large are undeniable. This case, if not overturned, stands to remove the protective boundaries surrounding what constitutes a property right versus a 'permitted use.' It will lay a marker regarding individuals' right to compensation for government takings. We strongly encourage the Supreme Court to take up this case."

PLC has represented livestock ranchers who use public lands since 1968, preserving the natural resources and unique heritage of the West. Public land ranchers own nearly 120 million acres of the most productive private land and manage vast areas of public land, accounting for critical wildlife habitat and the nation's natural resources. PLC works to maintain a stable business environment in which livestock producers can conserve the West and feed the nation and world.

Date: 4/1/2013

Web hpj.com

Copyright 1995-2014.  High Plains Publishers, Inc.  All rights reserved.  Any republishing of these pages, including electronic reproduction of the editorial archives or classified advertising, is strictly prohibited. If you have questions or comments you can reach us at
High Plains Journal 1500 E. Wyatt Earp Blvd., P.O. Box 760, Dodge City, KS 67801 or call 1-800-452-7171. Email: webmaster@hpj.com


Archives Search

NCBA Convention

United Sorghum Checkoff Program

Inside Futures

Editorial Archives

Browse Archives