0618ImpactofTransportationo.cfm 0618ImpactofTransportationo.cfm Study shows impact of transportation costs on farmer profitability
Home News Livestock Crops Markets Hay, Range & Pasture Home & Family Classifieds Resources This Week's Journal
Agro-Culture Liquid Fertilizer

Farm Survey

Journal Getaways

Reader Comment:
by ohio bo

"An excellent essay on fairs that brought back many memories for me. In my part"....Read the story...
Join other discussions.

Study shows impact of transportation costs on farmer profitability


Analysis performed on behalf of the Soy Transportation Coalition documents the strong relationship between our nation's freight transportation system and individual farmer profitability. The study provides compelling evidence that farmers, more than any other segment of agriculture, are responsible for paying the transportation costs from the farm to the dinner plate.

The study, performed by O'Neil Commodity Consulting, examined 36 soybean loading facilities across seven states (Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, and South Dakota) and analyzed the relationship among origin basis, destination basis, and transportation costs. The resulting graphs from the analysis all exhibit how transportation costs are disproportionately absorbed by farmers via a declining origin basis.

Dean Campbell, a soybean producer from Coulterville, Ill., and chair of the Soy Transportation Coalition explains the inherent challenges of conducting such a study, "The price a farmer receives for any commodity is determined by a complex assortment of issues. Trying to single out transportation's role in determining prices is difficult, but as we discovered in conducting the study, it is possible to provide greater clarity to this issue and allow farmers to more accurately see how transportation has a major impact on our individual bottom line. Farmers should therefore be among the leading advocates for a well-maintained, reliable transportation system."

The report specifically identifies how in periods of strong worldwide demand (a "demand pull" market), the ultimate customer will pay the costs--including transportation costs--for obtaining the shipment of soybeans. However, the report notes, "after the temporary demand pull is over, the market will always adjust/correct and any increases in transportation costs will always be passed back to producers." Over the long term, as the report highlights, agriculture is a "supply push" market due to strong competition from other grain and oilseed producing nations--resulting in transportation costs being disproportionately passed back to producers.

The graphs from the 36 soybean loading facilities provide examples of when the relationship between transportation and farmer income is strongest ("supply push" market) and when it is the weakest ("demand pull" market). As transportation costs rise, origin basis diminishes. This is particularly the case from 2004 to 2008, a period largely categorized as a "supply push" market.

"This analysis truly highlights how farmer profitability is dependent upon a number of items out of our control," explains Norm Husa, a soybean producer from Barneston, Neb., and board member of the Soy Transportation Coalition. "When reviewing the data and corresponding graphs, one can clearly see the role that worldwide supply and demand and transportation costs play in establishing the prices we receive. Farmers may be tempted to believe that once their grain has been delivered, any subsequent transportation costs are the problem of the elevator. In reality, these costs are our problem. Farmers should therefore be active to ensure we have a transportation system that is not an obstacle to our profitability."

The entire study, along with the individual graphs and data from the 36 soybean loading facilities, can be accessed at www.soytransportation.org.

Web hpj.com

Copyright 1995-2014.  High Plains Publishers, Inc.  All rights reserved.  Any republishing of these pages, including electronic reproduction of the editorial archives or classified advertising, is strictly prohibited. If you have questions or comments you can reach us at
High Plains Journal 1500 E. Wyatt Earp Blvd., P.O. Box 760, Dodge City, KS 67801 or call 1-800-452-7171. Email: webmaster@hpj.com


Archives Search

Inside Futures

Editorial Archives

Browse Archives