Home News Livestock Crops Markets Hay, Range & Pasture Home & Family Classifieds Resources This Week's Journal


AgriMartin

High Plains Journal online store


2008 Farm Publication Editorial Poll

Place HPJ classified ad

Reader Comment:
by Gold
"I really love reading articles that has lots of knowledge to impart. I admire those"....Read the story...
Join other discussions.

Guilt factor does nothing to improve environment

Here in Iowa we have a state-wide newspaper by the name of the Des Moines Register that has a long term tendency to use a lot of environmental type literature. Sometimes they go to extremes to the point of making it seem that if you happen to live in Iowa you are automatically guilty of something or other just because they found some educated nobody that can sit in his ivory tower and point his finger.

Of course, the newspaper will always find an excuse to not be able to print an objection to such nonsense, so I'm writing this to the High Plains Journal knowing very well that it isn't just an Iowa problem.

The article was on the editorial page of the Sept. 19 issue and submitted by Neil D. Hamilton, professor of law and director of the Agriculture Law Center at Drake University.

The article starts out about "how little politicians did to improve Iowa's environment." Then he makes the point that, "This responsibility is one we share as citizens, especially if "we own any of Iowa's land." Then he suggests, "10 actions to consider."

I'll not bother you with the details except to say that he keeps coming back to the "your land" bit, as in, "especially if we own any of Iowa's land."

My thoughts on such insinuations are that in the case of soil erosion we, the owners, have saved more top soil by accident than any lawyer will ever save on purpose.

So how do I justify a thought like that? Well, much of Iowa is hills and valleys. In other areas, those hills and valleys are used for grass and legume production rather than row crops.

Anyone that's been out in the sun far enough would know the only reason we've got a layer of top soil is because the grass has kept the soil from eroding away. It also, over the eons, has decomposed into more top soil. Compare this to what would be left on top if not for this accident of nature.

May I suggest that the various extremist environmentalists should stop emphasizing the guilt factor and instead emphasize the innocence factor. Even I know there to be varying degrees of innocence.

--Dwight Joy, Humeston, Iowa

10/8/07
4 Star NE\4-B

Date: 10/3/07


Click for related articles More FMD, bluetongue found in UK livestock
Morrell plant in Sioux City adds about 250 jobs
NCF- Students encouraged to apply for Beef Industry Scholarship
Nebraska Cattlemen matching producers involved with emergency h
Nelson elected to National Junior Red Angus board
New faculty members at NCTA ready to take college to next level

Comments on Articles article 2007- 41 - Guiltfactordoesnothingtoimp.cfm

Article: Guilt factor does nothing to improve environment

Add Your Comment
To post a comment on this story, enter your screen name and email address then click "Add Comment." Your email address will not be displayed.

150 Recommend | 0 Comments


Agriculture News from HPJ - Your Ag News Source
Google
 
Web hpj.com
Copyright/Privacy
Copyright 1995-2009.  High Plains Publishers, Inc.  All rights reserved.  Any republishing of these pages, including electronic reproduction of the editorial archives or classified advertising, is strictly prohibited. If you have questions or comments you can reach us at
High Plains Journal 1500 E. Wyatt Earp Blvd., P.O. Box 760, Dodge City, KS 67801 or call 1-800-452-7171. Email: webmaster@hpj.com



Market Snapshot

Inside Futures
Editorial Archives

Browse Archives

archives/2007/oct07/oct8/Guiltfactordoesnothingtoimp.cfm